Jonathan Stark

November 16, 2026

Want a grande iced caramel brûlée latte?

Buyers won’t pay more for a thing than it is worth to them.

Sounds obvious, right?

But how do they decide what something is worth to them?

Most of the time, it’s gut instinct.

Consider your own buying behavior.

You look at the grande iced caramel brûlée latte on the menu, see the price is $7.75, and instantly know whether that amount is more or less than the coffee is worth to you in the moment.

Things that can contribute to your gut reaction might include:

Notice what’s not on this list?

How much it costs Starbucks to make a grande iced caramel brûlée latte!

If a grande iced caramel brûlée latte isn’t worth $7.75 to you, could the barista change your mind by presenting you with a spreadsheet listing the price of all the ingredients that went into the drink?

What if the list also had line items for the cup, the electricity to run the coffee maker, a five-minute portion of the barista’s pay, etc?

Even if Starbucks proved to you that they were losing money on the beverage, I’d bet it still wouldn’t convince you to buy it.

Here’s the thing...

When I talk about “what something is worth,” what I’m really talking about is value.

What is value?

Value is a perception in the mind of a buyer.

You can think of value as the maximum amount someone would pay for a thing in the moment.

It’s important to note that value is NOT a characteristic of the thing being sold.

(If we go back to the coffee example, notice that the same buyer in different situations will place a different value on the exact same beverage - e.g., “already had too much coffee that day”).

You can’t calculate the VALUE of a thing by adding up all the costs it took to make the thing.

Yes, your costs determine the lowest price you can sell something for profitably, but for the price to be acceptable to a buyer, it has to be lower than the perceived value in their mind (i.e., what it’s worth to them).

For a purchase to take place, the seller’s COST has to be lower than the PRICE, and the PRICE has to be lower than the buyer’s perceived VALUE.

One implication of this immutable law is this:

If the thing you normally sell is so costly to deliver (i.e., it’s a ton of work for you) that it forces the price to be higher than what it’s worth to the buyer, the only possible solutions are:

  1. Increase the perceived value in the mind of the buyer
  2. Decrease your cost of delivery

Option one is very hard because it’s largely out of your control.

Option two is easier and completely in your control, but might require you to package your expertise in a whole new way.

My advice? Start working on both.

Yours,

—J

BackRandomNext